Why fake police offer scams work, according to Sophie van der Zee

The number of incidents involving fake police officers keeps rising. So far this year, the Dutch police have counted 14,000. Criminals pose as officers, call older people with a story about burglars in the neighbourhood, and then take their money and valuables. According to Sophie van der Zee, Associate Professor and lie expert at Erasmus School of Economics, these scams work so well because you simply cannot see whether someone is telling the truth. 

What makes a good liar? 

Host Roos Abelman begins the topic on NPO Radio 1 programme Spraakmakers by emphasising how there is still too little being done against fake police officers and to protect the elderly. ‘You cannot see whether someone is not telling the truth, which is why these kinds of scams work so well,’ explains Van der Zee.  

Abelman asks her what makes someone a good liar. ‘Charismatic people who can tell a good story are more quickly believed,’ she begins. On top of that, being seen as trustworthy comes down to ‘facial features, the clothes one wears. In this case, people dress in uniform.’ Even attractiveness determines your trustworthiness. 

Van der Zee also explores the importance of always having a good answer. ‘They do their homework,’ she says. ‘They could have your phone number, children’s names.’ They gather all kinds of information about their victims in advance to make a compelling story, through social media or data leaks. 

Importance for children and grandchildren 

Even the police admit that it is difficult to differentiate between a real and a fake officer when it comes down to outward signs such as a uniform or the car they drive. This ties in with what Van der Zee says, as the entirety of the picture makes it psychologically easier to believe someone. 

Victims are normally 70 or older, and are hard to reach through the usual communication channels, let alone social media campaigns. The police therefore stress the role of children and grandchildren in protecting their parents and grandparents. 

Associate professor
More information

You can listen to the full broadcast of Spraakmakers by NPO Radio 1, 16 November 2026, here (in Dutch). The item starts at 3:22.

For more information, please contact Ronald de Groot, Media and Public Relations Officer at Erasmus School of Economics, rdegroot@ese.eur.nl, or +31 6 53 641 846.

Related content
According to Sophie van der Zee, criminals are increasingly using artificial intelligence (AI) to make fraudulent rental advertisements more convincing.
Sophie van der Zee

Compare 0 study programme